AI written text that does not sound like AI

What makes writing sound like a machine, how you fix it, and why it matters for trust and for sales.

Content Co-founder of Galdrasmiðjan Published 2026-09-047 min read
A glass inkwell filled with glowing orange ink and a steel pen lying beside it

In short

  • Readers spot AI writing by its rhythm, not by its words.
  • Three tells give it away every time: no names, no numbers, no opinion.
  • The best cure is one fact from your own business in every single paragraph.
  • AI is excellent at drafts and terrible at finishing.
  • Google does not penalise AI. It penalises writing that says nothing.

There is nothing wrong with writing with AI. We do it ourselves, every day, and we do not hide it. The problem is not the tool. The problem is what happens when nobody reads it back: the writing goes smooth, polite and completely empty.

Three tells that give the machine away

1. No names and no numbers

AI writes “many customers experience significant benefits”. A person writes “Kim Yong Wings got 141 reviews and a 4.8 rating in its first two years”. Numbers and names are the hardest things for a machine to fake, because it does not know them.

2. Balance about everything

The machine wants to show every side of every question and land on a polite conclusion. A person with experience tells you what works and what does not. A sentence like “Wix is sometimes the right answer and we say so” could never come out of automated marketing copy.

3. A rhythm that never breaks

Three sentences per paragraph, all the same length, every paragraph the same size. Real writing has an uneven rhythm. Sometimes a short sentence lands. Then a longer one that explains why it matters and what it actually means for the person reading it.

The machine writes what anyone could say. Your job is to write what nobody but you can say.

How we actually work

  1. Gather the facts first. Numbers, names, prices, examples from your own business. This is the one part AI cannot do for you.
  2. Let the machine draft from those facts, not from the topic in general.
  3. Cut everything that could sit on any website in the world.
  4. Add one opinion. What do you genuinely think, that somebody could disagree with?
  5. Read it out loud. Wherever you stumble, the writing is wrong.

What about Google?

Google does not penalise you for using AI. It penalises content that helps nobody. An article that answers a real question with real information ranks, whoever wrote the first draft. An empty article does not rank, whoever wrote it.

The same holds in AI search. These systems cite sources that have something to say: numbers, names, examples and a named author.

Icelandic in particular

AI writes decent Icelandic today, but it does two things that always need fixing. It carries English rhythm straight over, which gives you sentences that are grammatically correct and sound nothing like the way people talk. And it reaches for vocabulary that is too formal, because formal text makes up a bigger share of what it has read in Icelandic.

A simple test: would you say this out loud to a customer over a cup of coffee? If not, write it again.

Frequently asked questions

Should I disclose that AI was involved in the writing?

You are not legally required to. We say it anyway, because it is part of how we work and people appreciate the honesty. The important thing is that a person takes responsibility for what is on the page.

What about images?

Same rule. AI images are fine for concepts, backgrounds and metaphors. For people, products and places, use real photographs. Faces nobody recognises destroy trust faster than anything else.

Can you write for us?

Yes, that is Efnissmiðjan, our content service. We interview you to get the facts and the voice, and then you get to go about your life while we write.

About the author

is co-founder of galdrasmiðjan. He builds websites and online stores for Icelandic companies and writes here about what actually works: speed, search, visibility in AI answers and automation.

Questions about this article go to hallo@galdrasmidjan.is.

Want us to look at your site?

We take a short call, look at where things stand and tell you what is worth fixing first. It costs nothing.

Get a fixed quote